DRD Team • Intel HD 3000 slow in skulltag - Page 2

Page 2 of 2

Re: Intel HD 3000 slow in skulltag

Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2012 20:32

by Graf Zahl

Ok, here you got it:

http://depositfiles.com/files/7zxayuvgh

I put all the WADs and other required files together so it's quite large.

What you need to do is, first bind the 'bench' console command to a key ('bind {key} bench') load one after another, press that key and when you are done, take the 'benchmark.txt file and post it here.

(And sorry that I couldn't find a better filehost. This was the only one which let me upload stuff without registering first.)

Re: Intel HD 3000 slow in skulltag

Posted: Tue Jun 05, 2012 0:06

by ibm5155

it´s ok, if i can download it ^^
thanks again Graf

edit i got a corrupted file ¬¬ but i think it was the wifi, the conection crashed one time...
downloading agin

Re: Intel HD 3000 slow in skulltag

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 2:38

by ibm5155

Tested with gzdoom factory config (just i hide the doom face hud for the simple hud with some numbers...)
Dark Hour

Spoiler:
Map map04: "Mos Denra Space Port",
x = -3274.4546, y = 5024.6348, z = -87.0000, angle = 7.8662, pitch = -1.1810
Walls: 2476 (0 splits, 0 t-splits, 6036 vertices)
Flats: 415 (1147 primitives, 4831 vertices)
Sprites: 167, Decals=0
W: Render=2.113, Split = 0.000, Setup=0.637, Clip=0.669
F: Render=10.345, Setup=0.144
S: Render=1.171, Setup=0.109
All=16.886, Render=14.515, Setup=1.893, BSP = 0.333, Portal=0.058, Finish=0.335
DLight - Walls: 0 processed, 0 rendered - Flats: 0 processed, 0 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
59 fps

EDIT:800x600, radial fog, and quality render

Spoiler:
Map map04: "Mos Denra Space Port",
x = -3274.4546, y = 5024.6348, z = -87.0000, angle = 7.8662, pitch = -1.1810
Walls: 2476 (0 splits, 0 t-splits, 10069 vertices)
Flats: 415 (1147 primitives, 4831 vertices)
Sprites: 167, Decals=0
W: Render=2.724, Split = 0.000, Setup=0.625, Clip=0.652
F: Render=9.961, Setup=0.141
S: Render=1.212, Setup=0.106
All=16.973, Render=14.721, Setup=1.846, BSP = 0.320, Portal=0.086, Finish=0.263
DLight - Walls: 0 processed, 0 rendered - Flats: 0 processed, 0 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
58 fps

Epic

Spoiler:
Map map05: "The Citadel",
x = 252.0824, y = -7923.5792, z = 41.0000, angle = 91.6974, pitch = 0.0000
Walls: 4858 (0 splits, 22 t-splits, 13376 vertices)
Flats: 163 (2856 primitives, 15566 vertices)
Sprites: 537, Decals=0
W: Render=4.321, Split = 0.000, Setup=1.235, Clip=0.888
F: Render=8.012, Setup=0.164
S: Render=4.575, Setup=0.286
All=22.540, Render=18.916, Setup=3.155, BSP = 0.575, Portal=0.319, Finish=0.359
DLight - Walls: 0 processed, 0 rendered - Flats: 0 processed, 0 rendered
Missing textures: 2 upper, 0 lower, 0.006 ms
42 fps

EDIT:800x600, radial fog, and quality render

Spoiler:
Map map05: "The Citadel",
x = 252.0824, y = -7923.5792, z = 41.0000, angle = 91.6974, pitch = 0.0000
Walls: 4858 (0 splits, 22 t-splits, 22855 vertices)
Flats: 163 (2856 primitives, 15566 vertices)
Sprites: 537, Decals=0
W: Render=5.698, Split = 0.000, Setup=1.266, Clip=0.880
F: Render=8.581, Setup=0.164
S: Render=4.674, Setup=0.292
All=25.533, Render=21.159, Setup=3.186, BSP = 0.577, Portal=0.617, Finish=1.076
DLight - Walls: 0 processed, 0 rendered - Flats: 0 processed, 0 rendered
Missing textures: 2 upper, 0 lower, 0.007 ms
41 fps

Hell core

Spoiler:
Map map09: "hobb's end horror",
x = -2948.9402, y = -3467.5623, z = 681.0000, angle = 270.0110, pitch = 13.3594
Walls: 6421 (0 splits, 548 t-splits, 13516 vertices)
Flats: 2046 (11582 primitives, 60080 vertices)
Sprites: 150, Decals=0
W: Render=5.883, Split = 0.000, Setup=1.531, Clip=1.154
F: Render=33.417, Setup=0.306
S: Render=1.196, Setup=0.220
All=46.809, Render=42.296, Setup=3.922, BSP = 0.705, Portal=0.000, Finish=0.478
DLight - Walls: 0 processed, 0 rendered - Flats: 0 processed, 0 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 7 lower, 0.006 ms
21 fps

EDIT:800x600, radial fog, and quality render

Spoiler:
Map map09: "hobb's end horror",
x = -2948.9402, y = -3467.5623, z = 681.0000, angle = 270.0110, pitch = 13.3594
Walls: 6421 (0 splits, 548 t-splits, 21043 vertices)
Flats: 2046 (11582 primitives, 60080 vertices)
Sprites: 150, Decals=0
W: Render=7.453, Split = 0.000, Setup=1.518, Clip=1.113
F: Render=31.253, Setup=0.307
S: Render=1.188, Setup=0.221
All=46.056, Render=41.635, Setup=3.847, BSP = 0.682, Portal=0.000, Finish=0.471
DLight - Walls: 0 processed, 0 rendered - Flats: 0 processed, 0 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 7 lower, 0.006 ms
22 fps

BGPA

Spoiler:
Map map110: "Inca H.Q.",
x = -1471.8534, y = -117.2836, z = 52.0000, angle = 356.4844, pitch = 0.0000
Walls: 2610 (0 splits, 60 t-splits, 15412 vertices)
Flats: 1305 (5820 primitives, 32458 vertices)
Sprites: 201, Decals=5
W: Render=6.149, Split = 0.312, Setup=1.040, Clip=0.614
F: Render=29.323, Setup=0.313
S: Render=3.527, Setup=0.143
All=44.311, Render=40.763, Setup=2.751, BSP = 0.329, Portal=0.411, Finish=0.348
DLight - Walls: 291 processed, 18 rendered - Flats: 338 processed, 51 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
22 fps

EDIT:800x600, radial fog, and quality render

Spoiler:
Map map110: "Inca H.Q.",
x = -1471.8534, y = -117.2836, z = 52.0000, angle = 356.4844, pitch = 0.0000
Walls: 2610 (0 splits, 60 t-splits, 39342 vertices)
Flats: 1305 (5869 primitives, 32744 vertices)
Sprites: 201, Decals=5
W: Render=7.294, Split = 0.318, Setup=1.078, Clip=0.646
F: Render=28.348, Setup=0.316
S: Render=3.583, Setup=0.151
All=44.912, Render=41.130, Setup=2.847, BSP = 0.335, Portal=0.458, Finish=0.473
DLight - Walls: 318 processed, 26 rendered - Flats: 402 processed, 57 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
21 fps

Operation Overlord

Spoiler:
Map MAP01: "Operation Overlord",
x = -282.6588, y = -5.0981, z = 57.0000, angle = 88.4619, pitch = -5.7843
Walls: 1691 (0 splits, 14 t-splits, 4728 vertices)
Flats: 195 (1022 primitives, 5793 vertices)
Sprites: 534, Decals=3
W: Render=2.646, Split = 0.000, Setup=0.727, Clip=0.598
F: Render=8.229, Setup=0.162
S: Render=6.411, Setup=0.324
All=21.037, Render=18.313, Setup=2.156, BSP = 0.342, Portal=0.413, Finish=0.153
DLight - Walls: 68 processed, 10 rendered - Flats: 49 processed, 38 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
54 fps

EDIT:800x600, radial fog, and quality render

Spoiler:
Map MAP01: "Operation Overlord",
x = -282.6588, y = -5.0981, z = 57.0000, angle = 88.4619, pitch = -5.7843
Walls: 1691 (0 splits, 14 t-splits, 7513 vertices)
Flats: 195 (1022 primitives, 5793 vertices)
Sprites: 534, Decals=3
W: Render=2.456, Split = 0.000, Setup=0.455, Clip=0.375
F: Render=5.411, Setup=0.096
S: Render=4.083, Setup=0.183
All=14.714, Render=12.800, Setup=1.354, BSP = 0.243, Portal=0.400, Finish=0.229
DLight - Walls: 69 processed, 11 rendered - Flats: 50 processed, 39 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
61 fps

Phobia

Spoiler:
Map map05: "Phobia - blood",
x = -5761.9960, y = -221.1006, z = 43.0000, angle = 2.6917, pitch = 0.0000
Walls: 2324 (0 splits, 0 t-splits, 38356 vertices)
Flats: 3022 (11097 primitives, 47878 vertices)
Sprites: 38, Decals=0
W: Render=8.941, Split = 1.189, Setup=2.166, Clip=0.504
F: Render=29.964, Setup=0.690
S: Render=0.432, Setup=0.106
All=47.419, Render=42.034, Setup=5.066, BSP = 0.409, Portal=0.168, Finish=0.219
DLight - Walls: 0 processed, 0 rendered - Flats: 0 processed, 0 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
20 fps

EDIT:800x600, radial fog, and quality render

Spoiler:
Map map05: "Phobia - blood",
x = -5761.9960, y = -221.1006, z = 43.0000, angle = 2.6917, pitch = 0.0000
Walls: 2324 (0 splits, 0 t-splits, 535262 vertices)
Flats: 3022 (11097 primitives, 47878 vertices)
Sprites: 38, Decals=0
W: Render=12.145, Split = 1.235, Setup=2.365, Clip=0.665
F: Render=31.888, Setup=0.719
S: Render=0.455, Setup=0.118
All=53.514, Render=47.303, Setup=5.550, BSP = 0.446, Portal=0.337, Finish=0.557
DLight - Walls: 0 processed, 0 rendered - Flats: 0 processed, 0 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
19 fps

Both sonic maps in one spolier

Spoiler:
Map map02: "sunset island zone - act 2",
x = -80.7690, y = -268.2019, z = 73.0000, angle = 87.5446, pitch = 0.1428
Walls: 1256 (0 splits, 7 t-splits, 2316 vertices)
Flats: 102 (1086 primitives, 5836 vertices)
Sprites: 277, Decals=3
W: Render=0.877, Split = 0.000, Setup=0.362, Clip=0.376
F: Render=3.452, Setup=0.104
S: Render=2.174, Setup=0.143
All=12.906, Render=8.187, Setup=1.266, BSP = 0.276, Portal=2.909, Finish=0.406
DLight - Walls: 0 processed, 0 rendered - Flats: 0 processed, 0 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 1 lower, 0.001 ms
71 fps

Map map10: "forest fortress zone - act 2",
x = 554.2964, y = 1039.6241, z = 169.0000, angle = 179.0277, pitch = 0.0000
Walls: 2911 (0 splits, 481 t-splits, 8672 vertices)
Flats: 155 (1928 primitives, 9234 vertices)
Sprites: 653, Decals=0
W: Render=4.538, Split = 0.000, Setup=0.891, Clip=0.735
F: Render=10.102, Setup=0.139
S: Render=7.217, Setup=0.420
All=32.215, Render=24.362, Setup=2.720, BSP = 0.517, Portal=5.019, Finish=0.173
DLight - Walls: 0 processed, 0 rendered - Flats: 0 processed, 0 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
36 fps

EDIT:800x600, radial fog, and quality render

Spoiler:
Map map02: "sunset island zone - act 2",
x = -80.7690, y = -268.2019, z = 73.0000, angle = 87.5446, pitch = 0.1428
Walls: 1473 (0 splits, 11 t-splits, 5384 vertices)
Flats: 169 (1461 primitives, 7832 vertices)
Sprites: 503, Decals=3
W: Render=1.431, Split = 0.000, Setup=0.366, Clip=0.390
F: Render=4.928, Setup=0.068
S: Render=3.899, Setup=0.155
All=19.799, Render=12.502, Setup=1.284, BSP = 0.300, Portal=5.792, Finish=0.279
DLight - Walls: 0 processed, 0 rendered - Flats: 0 processed, 0 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 1 lower, 0.000 ms
48 fps

Map map10: "forest fortress zone - act 2",
x = 554.2964, y = 1039.6241, z = 169.0000, angle = 179.0277, pitch = 0.0000
Walls: 2911 (0 splits, 481 t-splits, 17270 vertices)
Flats: 155 (1928 primitives, 9234 vertices)
Sprites: 653, Decals=0
W: Render=3.731, Split = 0.000, Setup=0.806, Clip=0.686
F: Render=6.424, Setup=0.125
S: Render=5.262, Setup=0.297
All=24.743, Render=17.326, Setup=2.389, BSP = 0.461, Portal=4.796, Finish=0.282
DLight - Walls: 0 processed, 0 rendered - Flats: 0 processed, 0 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
39 fps

TUTNT

Spoiler:
Map tnt04cn: "The Beginning and The End",
x = -485.0361, y = -5971.7348, z = 3904.7230, angle = 83.1665, pitch = 38.2214
Walls: 5369 (0 splits, 2 t-splits, 28128 vertices)
Flats: 1000 (8389 primitives, 44515 vertices)
Sprites: 1360, Decals=0
W: Render=15.969, Split = 0.429, Setup=1.487, Clip=1.267
F: Render=45.662, Setup=0.363
S: Render=11.721, Setup=0.612
All=84.514, Render=77.511, Setup=4.873, BSP = 0.707, Portal=2.456, Finish=0.423
DLight - Walls: 413 processed, 108 rendered - Flats: 1403 processed, 746 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
11 fps

EDIT:800x600, radial fog, and quality render

Spoiler:
Map tnt04cn: "The Beginning and The End",
x = -485.0361, y = -5971.7348, z = 3906.9752, angle = 83.1665, pitch = 38.2214
Walls: 5369 (0 splits, 2 t-splits, 116128 vertices)
Flats: 1000 (8389 primitives, 44515 vertices)
Sprites: 1365, Decals=0
W: Render=17.090, Split = 0.422, Setup=1.414, Clip=1.192
F: Render=43.351, Setup=0.348
S: Render=11.631, Setup=0.609
All=83.392, Render=76.306, Setup=4.670, BSP = 0.675, Portal=3.176, Finish=0.209
DLight - Walls: 413 processed, 95 rendered - Flats: 1398 processed, 742 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
11 fps

Zpack

Spoiler:
Map e1m0: "Colossus reloaded",
x = -799.7151, y = -312.3973, z = -87.0000, angle = 359.1595, pitch = 0.3076
Walls: 2772 (0 splits, 24 t-splits, 23192 vertices)
Flats: 1119 (5498 primitives, 28198 vertices)
Sprites: 83, Decals=0
W: Render=9.208, Split = 0.403, Setup=0.954, Clip=0.991
F: Render=31.741, Setup=0.384
S: Render=0.863, Setup=0.168
All=67.453, Render=46.294, Setup=3.749, BSP = 0.689, Portal=18.012, Finish=0.240
DLight - Walls: 161 processed, 36 rendered - Flats: 648 processed, 321 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
14 fps

EDIT:800x600, radial fog, and quality render

Spoiler:
Map e1m0: "Colossus reloaded",
x = -799.7151, y = -312.3973, z = -87.0000, angle = 359.1595, pitch = 0.3076
Walls: 2772 (0 splits, 24 t-splits, 139832 vertices)
Flats: 1119 (5498 primitives, 28198 vertices)
Sprites: 83, Decals=0
W: Render=10.210, Split = 0.548, Setup=1.336, Clip=1.254
F: Render=36.384, Setup=0.508
S: Render=0.844, Setup=0.199
All=78.718, Render=52.477, Setup=4.874, BSP = 0.824, Portal=22.359, Finish=0.494
DLight - Walls: 159 processed, 32 rendered - Flats: 588 processed, 291 rendered
Missing textures: 0 upper, 0 lower, 0.000 ms
14 fps

Hmm should i used lights.pk3 and some specific resolution? (640x480 here i think)

EDIT 2 simplified results (before ,640x480, fog standart, render speed, and dark light, after:800x600, fog radial, render quality, doom light)

Spoiler:
Dark Hour
-Before:59fps
-After:58fps
-Difference:1fps

Epic
-Before:42fps
-After:41fps
-Difference:-1fps

Hell Core
-Before:21fps
-After:22fps
-Difference:1fps

BGPA
-Before:22fps
-After:21fps
-Difference:-1fps

Operation Overlord
-Before:54fps
-After:61fps
-Difference:7fps O_O

Phobia
-Before20fps
-After:19fps
-Difference:-1fps

Sonic island
-Before:71fps
-After:48fps
-Difference:-23fps

Sonic fortress
-Before:36fps
-After:34fps
-Difference:-2fps

Tutnt
-Before:11fps
-After:11fps
-Difference:0fps

Zpack
-Before:14fps
-After:14fps
-Difference:0fps

EDIT:no savegame for phobos anomaly =/

Re: Intel HD 3000 slow in skulltag

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 8:05

by Graf Zahl

Ok, interesting numbers. They tell me that the rendering power of it isn't really that bad - but the driver sucks badly. There's way too much overhead in it that slows things down dramatically.

Re: Intel HD 3000 slow in skulltag

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 15:42

by ibm5155

well, they´re now more focused in intel HD 4000 drivers .-. , so i can´t expect some new driver for my gpu, at least i´ll check if have some news...

I think for me it´s strange, resolution and fog even change the results in most of the cases, and i think the problem isn´t with dynamic lights and that things (i could have 25 fps with more than 100 plasma balls near to the wall/ceiling), but yes the size of the map drawed on the screen...

Do you think if i got more one 4GB ddr3 ram it would help it? why i think that, what i have seen if i get it, if i have a single memory it would run at 64bits and with two it would run at 128bits...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tTdEEgN-UAg <= i see it have a nice performance in dual channel, could i get the same performance in doom if i get a 4GB ram?

Re: Intel HD 3000 slow in skulltag

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 20:04

by Graf Zahl

No, RAM won't help here.

The problem is not the hardware but the driver. It looks like it doesn't take any advantage whatsoever of multithreading and performs everything it can in the main application thread - including waiting for the result to be drawn. Of course that's slow - extremely slow in fact.

By comparison, the NVidia driver isn't doing anything significant in the application thread. It only sets up some data that's then being processed by a separate helper thread so in the time it gets processed the application can feed more data to the GPU. AMD seems to have the same problem, albeit not this pronounced.

Re: Intel HD 3000 slow in skulltag

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 21:20

by ibm5155

Drivers updated, i tested all again, results:1fps up in some mods xD (Tutnt) and others it stay the same (BGPA...)
and same results in the new gzdoom, i think i can´t do more things for up the fps, thanks Graf for the help.