Model different colour in different IWADs w/coloured lights

[Enjay]

Any idea why this might be happening? The following screenshots are taken in the same map but running under different IWADs.

All textures, model skins etc are in PNG format and so the game palette should not affect them. The area in question is lit using coloured sector lighting and a dynamic light. The mid-texture-like structure is actually a model. When the game is run using any Doom IWAD (doom.wad, doom2.wad, tnt.wad, plutonia.wad), the model is coloured much as I expect it to be. However, in any other game that I have tried, the model looks a little bit off colour.

[spoiler]Doom - looks about right:


Heretic - model looks a bit yellowy


Hexen - much the same


Strife - again, much the same


Harmony


Even Strife with the Doom palette and colormap loaded in a PWAD


And Chex, which surprised me


HacX too


But FreeDoom was OK
[/spoiler]

So, anyone know why this is? I'm guessing that there is a configuration setting somewhere that handles this situation slightly differently when the game is in Doom mode. I'm just intrigued to find out what it might be.

[Graf Zahl]

Post the map, not some screenshots and I might tell you. As it is: no idea. My first guess would be some dynamic light source that's only present in Doom, but how can I verify?

[Enjay]

I thought that might be the case. I was a bit rushed when I posted last night and didn't have time to package things up so my post was a bit of a reminder to myself to do so today and a hope that there might be an "off the top of the head" answer where this was simply a known about situation.

Anyway, attached is a cut down version of the area in question. It still shows in the way I posted above - i.e. the model is coloured more blue in Doom than in the other supported games.

[Graf Zahl]

Hm, that's odd. Are you using different GZDoom versions for the various games?

It looks like the Doom picture for me with the latest GLEW_Version build and like the Heretic pic with the latest official version.
The GLEW_Version color is the correct one, of course, it seems there's a color clipping bug in the official version.

[Enjay]

I get the same result with the Git build from 27 June and with 1.8.6 official. i.e. both EXE's display the map differently depending on the IWAD being used.

1.8.6
[spoiler]

[/spoiler]

Git
[spoiler]

[/spoiler]

[Enjay]

Got it! I had a feeling that it was the result of a config option somewhere. I deleted my ini and found that Doom started looking like the other games. After working through the options, I eventually tracked it down to the sector lighting mode. Doom was set to use the software emulation mode, the other games were not.

[Edward-san]

Is it there a reason why the option should not be propagated through all the games?

[Graf Zahl]

It's a per-game option and will stay that way. Users may prefer different settings for different games.